Why Your “Hot or Not” Score Doesn’t Matter

You might have heard of the infamous website: “Hot or Not” (http://hotornot.com).  People desiring to participate in this particular social experiment post the hottest picture of themselves they can rustle up, then take a deep breath and press “submit,” inviting mass evaluation from other users of the site.  Obviously, you hope for a high score…right?  [Out of pure journalistic curiosity, I gave this a try on Monday--since then, over 2,000 people have voted on my "hotness" (on a scale from 1 to 10), and some even joined my pool of "hot-mirers".  It's apparently also a dating site, which I didn't realize until I received a marriage proposal!  I had to decline, sorry about that Skinny16!

(Need to consult about your Hotmirers?  Find out how!)

Why do all of these people care about voting on the hotness of strangers?  HotorNot, and subsequent copycat sites, and basically the whole of high school and college, seem predicated on a three-tiered assumption-cake:

  • if lots of people agree you’re hot stuff, then you must be hot stuff
  • hot people have a better choice of lovers
  • people with more choices lead better, more satisfying lives

Wait, wait, wait.  You might have been eating this cake for years, but let’s take a closer look.  Does this "collective assessment" of your hotness really exist?  For it to matter what a group of voters think of your phizzog[i], it would need to be true that people generally agree on how good looking everyone is. But do they? In the mid-70s, a fellow named Murstein[ii] asked 98 young married couples to rate how attractive their spouse was.  Eight independent judges made the same ratings (based on photographs[iii]).   The judges, who were rather harsh in my opinion, only thought 21-24% of the spouses possessed “above average” attractiveness.  By contrast, a whopping 67% of wives and 85% of husbands thought their own spouse was average-average!  (85% of newly married husbands think their wife is hot—that made me happy).  Curiously, spouses thought they had hit the jackpot with their own spouse, while independent judges sat by, shaking their heads in pity.  At least 65% of husbands disagreed with the judges–that’s a lot of disparity! Such research makes me question Hotornot.com’s concept of a static level of attractiveness.  Is this really the right way to think about it?  Does it make more sense that I am quantitatively an 8, for example, or does it sound more likely that some people will think I’m a 6 while some very charitable soul will think I’m a 9?  Perhaps it is useful to know your “average”–and Hotornot.com will tell you that.  But it seems to me that beauty, within certain limitations, really is in the eye of the beholder. This conclusion clearly falls in the “fabulous news” category.  If people don’t agree on your hotness, that means you have a spectrum to work with, not just a number.  Maybe with your face, body, and personality, people rate you from a 5 to a 9.  Your “group think” score on Hot or Not might be a 6.5, but do you hear what I’m saying?   Who cares about that–there are people out there who think you’re a 9!  Here’s my advice:  date those people.  Make sure that other person thinks you’re hot stuff before you commit.  If someone’s not that into you, just remember this:  they don’t speak for everyone.  Forget them, and your “hot or not” score, and go find somebody who will be psyched to have you.

Need a Dating Consultation?  I’m a licensed counselor and I specialize in helping people who are single, dating, or engaged to understand and grow great relationships.  Click to Find Out More.


[i] “Phizzog” by Carl Sandburg This face you got, This here phizzog you carry around, You never picked it out for yourself at all, at all—-did you? This here phizzog—-somebody handed it to you–am I right? Somebody said, “Here’s yours, now go see what you can do with it.” Somebody slipped it to you and it was like a package marked: “No goods exchanged after being taken away”—- This face you got.
[ii] Murstein, B. I. (1976). Who will marry whom? Theories and research inmarital choice. New York: Springer.

[iii] While on the one hand, you could argue that people are better-looking in person than in photographs, anyone who has ever participated in on-line dating can tell you this isn’t the case.

About these ads

8 responses to “Why Your “Hot or Not” Score Doesn’t Matter

  1. Pingback: Wait…You Have TWO Blogs? « Beautiful Middle Country

  2. I own one of these knock off hot or not sites and have to agree with your research to a point. Generally speaking, the top ten results on the site are pretty bang on. Gorgeous, fit people. However, I do see the odd member that I think should easily make our top ten list and for some strange reason they do not even come close? In the end beauty IS in the eye of the beholder.

  3. Ahaa, its pleasant conversation regarding this article at this
    place at this weblog, I have read all that, so now me also commenting at thiss place.

  4. Your score means everything. Mine controls my self esteem and how I view myself.

  5. I enjoy what you guys are usually uup too. This sort oof cleger work and coverage!
    Keep up thhe good works guys I’ve added you guys to our
    blogroll.

  6. Aero Windwalker

    Melissa you are not hot.

Share Your Thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s